As property managers, we often get asked about the merits of investing in green upgrades for rental properties.

Investors are increasingly interested in how these improvements contribute to environmental sustainability and impact financial returns.

Green upgrades can be a smart move. The market is responding positively to properties that incorporate energy efficiency and sustainability. These investments often come with tax incentives, increasing their overall value​. 

Upgrades like energy-efficient windows and smart home technologies attract environmentally conscious tenants and lead to cost savings on energy bills, which can be a compelling selling point.

Understanding ROI in Green Upgrades

Return on Investment (ROI) measures the profitability of your investments, comparing the benefits you gain to the costs incurred.

Regarding green upgrades, the calculation includes direct financial gains, such as increased rent or property value, and savings through reduced utility costs and potential tax incentives.

Types of Green Upgrades

Green upgrades can range from simple enhancements to extensive renovations.

Energy-efficient appliances: Replacing old appliances like refrigerators, dishwashers, and washing machines with energy-efficient models reduces electricity and water usage.

Solar panels: Installing solar panels can significantly cut electricity bills and may qualify you for governmental rebates.

Insulation and windows: Enhancing insulation, sealing leaks, and installing energy-efficient windows help maintain indoor temperatures and reduce heating and cooling costs.

Smart home technology: Smart thermostats, lights, and water systems can automate energy savings, appealing to tech-savvy renters.

Benefits of Green Upgrades

Lower Operating Costs: Green technologies typically consume less energy and water, which can substantially lower utility bills. This is a tangible benefit that attracts cost-conscious tenants.

Increased Property Value: Properties with green certifications, like LEED or Energy Star, often command higher market values. They are also more competitive in the rental market, attracting tenants faster and potentially reducing vacancy rates.

Tax Incentives: Many local, state, and federal programs offer incentives for property owners to invest in energy-efficient upgrades. These can range from tax credits and rebates to grants, reducing the initial cost burden.

Marketability: Eco-friendly properties appeal to a growing demographic concerned with sustainability. These tenants are often willing to pay a premium for green features, which can translate into higher rents.

Regulatory Compliance: As environmental regulations tighten, investing in green upgrades preemptively can ensure compliance, avoiding future costs and disruptions.

Calculating ROI

You can gauge the potential return on your investment by subtracting the total costs from the sum of ongoing savings, increased rental income, tax benefits, and increased resale value.

Initial Costs: Determine the total cost of purchasing and installing the green upgrades.

Ongoing Savings: Estimate the monthly savings on utility bills and the potential increase in rental income.

Tax Breaks and Incentives: Factor in any governmental incentives that will offset the initial costs.

Increased Resale Value: Estimate how much the property's value will increase due to the upgrades.

Example of ROI Calculation

Let's calculate a basic ROI using energy-efficient windows as an example:

  1. Cost of Installation: Suppose it costs $10,000 to replace old windows with new, energy-efficient ones.
  2. Annual Savings: Energy-efficient windows can save between $126 to $465 annually in energy costs​​.
  3. Increased Rental Income: Assume you can charge an extra $50 per month due to these upgrades, equating to $600 per year.
  4. Tax Credits: Assume a tax credit of $500.

Calculate ROI using the formula:

ROI = (Total Benefits − Total Costs / Total Costs) × 100


  • Total Benefits = annual savings + increased rental income + tax credits = $726 to $1,065
  • Total Costs = cost of installation = $10,000

Assuming the maximum savings:

ROI = (1,065 − 10,000 / 10,000) × 100 = −89.35%

This negative ROI shows you'll need a long-term perspective; the initial years won't show a positive return. Instead, the savings will accumulate over time.

Let's Talk About Negative ROI

Understanding the initial negative ROI on green upgrades can be somewhat puzzling at first, but it makes sense when you consider the nature of such investments. Let's break it down into simpler terms

Upfront Costs: Green upgrades, such as installing energy-efficient windows, often come with significant upfront costs. For example, if it costs $10,000 to install these windows, that's a sizable initial expense. These costs include the materials, labor, and any disruption to your rental operations during installation.

Gradual Paybacks: The paybacks from these investments typically accrue over time rather than immediately. For instance, savings from reduced energy bills range from $126 to $465 per year. While these savings are beneficial, they are relatively small compared to the initial expense. This slow accumulation of benefits is a primary reason for the initial negative ROI.

Incremental Income Increases: Suppose you can charge $50 more monthly rent because of the perceived value of these upgrades. That adds up to $600 per year. While this helps, it still doesn't cover the initial investment.

Tax Credits: Tax credits like a $500 immediate rebate can help slightly reduce the cost burden but will not significantly impact the initial years following the upgrade.

Putting It All Together

When you calculate the ROI by subtracting the initial investment from the sum of these benefits and dividing it by the initial costs, you get a percentage that tells you how much of your investment you've earned back in a year. 

In this case: ROI = ($1,065 (max benefits per year) - $10,000 / $10,000) × 100 = −89.35%

This calculation shows that you are far from breaking even in the first year— hence the negative ROI. These sample numbers would take almost nine years to break even on the investment. However, it's crucial to consider the longer-term perspective:

Long-term Benefits

  • Energy savings and additional rent continue to accrue, providing ongoing benefits that improve ROI year over year.
  • Increased property value: These upgrades can significantly increase your property's market value. While this doesn't provide immediate cash flow, it is a critical financial benefit when you sell the property or refinance.
  • Attractiveness to tenants: Properties with green certifications or features often rent more quickly, reducing vacancy periods and attracting a higher caliber of tenants willing to pay more for sustainable living options.

While the initial ROI of green upgrades can be negative, the long-term financial, environmental, and marketability benefits can make these investments worthwhile. Considering these longer timelines and broader benefits is essential for a property owner when deciding on green upgrades.

Additionally, the increase in property value and the potential for higher rental prices should be factored into a more comprehensive ROI calculation over extended periods​.

Plan Ahead For The Future

Investing in green upgrades for rental properties is not just about contributing to environmental sustainability—it's also a strategic financial decision.

These improvements can enhance your property's value, reduce operational costs, and make your rental offering more attractive to a discerning tenant base. As regulations and tenant preferences evolve, property owners who act now will be well-positioned for future challenges and opportunities in the rental market.

While the initial ROI might appear low, the long-term benefits—such as increased property value, tenant attraction and retention, and operational cost savings—make this a worthwhile investment. As the market evolves, these features may become expected standards, positioning early adopters ahead in a competitive market.

If you'd like some help with investing - such as property management, or choosing the right property to start your portfolio, we're here to help. We know the Waco market like the back of our hand, and have been managing investments for years. Give us a call!


Be sure to follow us on YouTube, Facebook and Instagram!